← Articles

Butare-Smith et al: Double-loop cerclage resists greater loads for more cycles than twist and single-loop cerclage
Veterinary Surgery 2, 2022

🔍 Key Findings

  • Double-loop cerclage resisted the highest peak load (805 N) and maintained tension longer than twist (488 N) and single-loop (397 N) configurations.
  • Double-loop cerclage sustained 500,000 cycles at 60–80% of peak load in some cases without loosening, outperforming other types.
  • Twist knots loosened rapidly, often within 10 cycles even at low loads (100–390 N).
  • Single-loop knots performed better than twist, with partial resistance up to 100,000 cycles at 160 N, but showed wide variability.
  • All loosening occurred before wire breakage, indicating clinical failure would happen from slack, not fracture.
  • Double-loop cerclage had highest initial tension (323 N) compared to single-loop (124 N) and twist (69 N).
  • Fatigue limit was not identified for twist, since they all loosened early at even 20% of peak load.
  • Clinical recommendation: double-loop cerclage is best for resisting repeated subfailure loading, ideal for fissure prevention or fragment stabilization.

Simini Surgery Review Podcast

How critical is this paper for crushing the Boards?

🚨 Must-know. I’d bet on seeing this.

📚 Useful background, not must-know.

💤 Skip it. Doubt it’ll ever show up.

Thanks for the feedback!
‍We'll keep fine-tuning the articles vault.
Oops — didn’t go through.
‍Mind trying that again?
← Articles

Butare-Smith et al: Double-loop cerclage resists greater loads for more cycles than twist and single-loop cerclage
Veterinary Surgery 2, 2022

🔍 Key Findings

  • Double-loop cerclage resisted the highest peak load (805 N) and maintained tension longer than twist (488 N) and single-loop (397 N) configurations.
  • Double-loop cerclage sustained 500,000 cycles at 60–80% of peak load in some cases without loosening, outperforming other types.
  • Twist knots loosened rapidly, often within 10 cycles even at low loads (100–390 N).
  • Single-loop knots performed better than twist, with partial resistance up to 100,000 cycles at 160 N, but showed wide variability.
  • All loosening occurred before wire breakage, indicating clinical failure would happen from slack, not fracture.
  • Double-loop cerclage had highest initial tension (323 N) compared to single-loop (124 N) and twist (69 N).
  • Fatigue limit was not identified for twist, since they all loosened early at even 20% of peak load.
  • Clinical recommendation: double-loop cerclage is best for resisting repeated subfailure loading, ideal for fissure prevention or fragment stabilization.

Simini Surgery Review Podcast

Know What Matters in the Literature - and Why

We distill peer-reviewed surgical studies into clinically relevant summaries and
exam-style questions, so you can make informed decisions with confidence.

Free Access. No Spam. Just Smarter Surgical Learning

Multiple Choice Questions on this study

In Butare-Smith 2022 et al., on cerclage knot biomechanics, what was concluded about the clinical use of double-loop cerclage?

A. Unsuitable for clinical use
B. Inferior to twist knots
C. Equivalent to single-loop
D. Best for resisting repeated loads
E. Not used in orthopedic applications

Answer: Best for resisting repeated loads

Explanation: Authors concluded double-loop cerclage is most secure for managing fissures or fragment stabilization.
In Butare-Smith 2022 et al., on cerclage knot biomechanics, what was the peak load resisted by double-loop cerclage in single-load testing?

A. 397 N
B. 488 N
C. 640 N
D. 805 N
E. 124 N

Answer: 805 N

Explanation: Double-loop cerclage resisted a mean peak load of 805 N, the highest among all groups.
In Butare-Smith 2022 et al., on cerclage knot biomechanics, which cerclage knot had the **highest initial tension** before testing?

A. Twist knot (69 N)
B. Single-loop knot (124 N)
C. Double-loop knot (323 N)
D. Square knot (45 N)
E. All were equal

Answer: Double-loop knot (323 N)

Explanation: Double-loop had significantly higher resting tension, contributing to better fatigue resistance.
In Butare-Smith 2022 et al., on cerclage knot biomechanics, what was the typical failure mode of the twist cerclage under cyclic loading?

A. Wire breakage at knot
B. Wire slippage through bone
C. Knot tightening too much
D. Wire elongation over 3 mm
E. Knot untwisting and loosening

Answer: Knot untwisting and loosening

Explanation: Twist cerclage consistently failed by untwisting, often within 10 cycles.
In Butare-Smith 2022 et al., on cerclage knot biomechanics, which knot type demonstrated the highest resistance to cyclic loading before loosening?

A. Twist cerclage
B. Single-loop cerclage
C. Double-loop cerclage
D. Square knot cerclage
E. Knot-twist cerclage

Answer: Double-loop cerclage

Explanation: Double-loop cerclage resisted up to 500,000 cycles at high loads, outperforming other configurations.

Access the full library of surgical summaries and exam-style questions.

Get Instant Access

Educational content developed independently and supported by Simini.

The maker of Simini Protect Lavage.

Review More Key Summaries from this Veterinary Surgery Journal Issue

Karydas

 et al: 

Impact of postoperative radiography on the management of humeral condylar fractures in immature dogs

Smith

 et al: 

Variables associated with the prevalence of self-reported work-related musculoskeletal disorders in veterinary laparoscopic surgeons

Hildebrandt

 et al: 

Buccal transposition flap for closure of maxillary lip defects in 5 dogs

Mayhew

 et al: 

Effect of conventional multilevel brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome surgery on clinical and videofluoroscopic evidence of hiatal herniation and gastroesophageal reflux in dogs

Anderson

 et al: 

Application and influence of four drain configurations on fluid dispersal and retrieval in a cadaveric canine wound infusion-retrieval system model